The use of antivirus software is a must for most computer users, but there is some concern that systems being offered by other service sector companies could represent an invasion of personal data.
Take a new system which is being trialled by telecommunications group TalkTalk shortly. It claims to be able to spot websites that are infected by malware and then warn its customers. Antivirus software is traditionally provided by computer security companies, but now the sector is being opened up and profits enjoyed by the likes of McAfee and Symantec (developers of the Norton range of products) can be captured by more companies; especially those with large service customer bases.
Lofty ambitions from TalkTalk, but they have fallen foul of a regulator for not disclosing that the trial is going to take place. The regulator argues that they and TalkTalk customers should have been warned about the tests.
The controversy is brewing because of the concerns regarding a similar service, BT’s Webwise system. Devised by advertising agency Phorm, Webwise is able to track user behaviour, which allows an advertiser to target the user with more relevant advertisements.
It’s introduction and use has been met with wide scale user condemnation. The Phorm system has been almost universally decried because it collects the URLs visited by customers of companies.
The crux of the matter is whether such systems are used to
illegally intercept user data. It’s been reported that investigations have been launched The European Commission and UK police.
TalkTalk has got a slap on the wrist from the Information Commissioner’s Office for not disclosing more about the system it intends to use and the methodology of the trial.
Commissioner Christopher Graham said:
“I am concerned that the trial was undertaken without first informing those affected that it was taking place. In the light of the public reaction to BT’s trial of the proposed Webwise service I am disappointed to note that this particular trial was not mentioned to my officials during the latest of our liaison meetings.”
TalkTalk was shocked to hear of the Commission’s concerns and a spokesman said:
“We were simply looking at the urls accessed from our network, we weren’t looking at customer behaviour so we didn’t feel we were obliged to inform customers. It didn’t cross our minds that it would be compared to Phorm. This is all about protecting customers. It is not designed to provide us with data for any other purpose.”
TalkTalk were keen to distance itself from Phorm, even though it has been reported that the company was one of the three original ISPs which had signed up to the system.
And TalkTalk made the other point that their system would help their customers by providing a blacklist of websites that contained viruses and malware. Some 75,000 websites were found to have been a hiding place for a number of nasties.
Sector observers believe that as the computer security market broadens, the number of companies and organisations offering antivirus software solutions is set to increase.
The TalkTalk system is believed to go live at the end of 2010.
Guest Article by Neil Camp